Christmas in Italy vs. the United States: A Cultural Celebration of Tradition, Food, and Family
Christmas, or Natale as it’s called in Italy, is one of the most cherished and widely celebrated holidays around the world. But how this magical season unfolds varies significantly from one country to another. Two of the most fascinating and festive Christmas cultures are those of Italy and the United States. While both countries share the spirit of giving, beautiful decorations, and the joy of gathering around the table, the traditions, flavors, and timing of the celebration reveal deep cultural roots.
Let’s explore the unique ways Christmas is celebrated in Italy and the U.S.—from holiday meals and homemade pasta to Santa Claus and La Befana.
Timing: How Long Is the Holiday Season?
In the United States, the holiday season unofficially begins the day after Thanksgiving, on Black Friday, and lasts until December 25th. It’s a month filled with shopping, decorating, holiday movies, and festive gatherings. By the 26th, many Americans are already taking down decorations and heading out for post-Christmas sales. The season is short, energetic, and driven largely by commerce and celebration.
In contrast, Italy enjoys a longer and more spiritually rooted holiday calendar. Christmas officially kicks off on December 8th, the Feast of the Immaculate Conception, a national holiday when Italian families traditionally decorate their Christmas trees and nativity scenes. The season doesn’t end on Christmas Day—instead, it continues through Epiphany on January 6th, celebrated with the arrival of La Befana, the legendary gift-giving witch.
In Italy, the twelve days of Christmas aren’t just lyrics in a carol—they are lived and celebrated fully.
Religious vs. Secular: The Heart of the Celebration
Christmas in Italy is steeped in Catholic tradition. Across the country, you’ll find elaborate nativity scenes (presepi) in homes, churches, and piazzas. Some towns even stage live nativity reenactments, complete with animals and actors. Attending Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve is a cherished tradition, often followed by a late-night meal or toast.
In the United States, Christmas blends religious and secular elements. While many families attend church services, the broader celebration often revolves around Santa Claus, Christmas trees, and a sense of holiday magic inspired by movies, music, and nostalgia. American Christmas is a mix of many cultures—Irish, German, British, and more—all blended into a joyful and sometimes over-the-top celebration.
Who Brings the Gifts?
In the United States, Santa Claus reigns supreme. On Christmas Eve, children leave out milk and cookies, then rush to bed in hopes of waking up to a tree surrounded by presents.
Italy also celebrates Babbo Natale, but he’s a relatively recent addition to Italian traditions. The true holiday magic comes on the night of January 5th, when La Befana, a sweet old woman on a broomstick, brings candy or coal to children. According to legend, she was invited by the Three Wise Men to visit baby Jesus, and now, each year, she continues to search for him—leaving gifts in children’s stockings along the way.
This blend of folklore and faith gives Italy’s celebration a unique depth.
Holiday Meals: Pasta, Seafood & Family Recipes
One of the most delicious differences between the two countries is what’s on the Christmas table.
In the United States, Christmas dinner often mirrors Thanksgiving: roast turkey or ham, mashed potatoes, green beans, stuffing, and pies like pumpkin or apple. Cookies and peppermint bark are popular desserts, and eggnog is a holiday favorite.
But in Italy, Christmas food is sacred—and incredibly regional. While each part of the country has its own specialties, some traditions are celebrated nationwide:
- Christmas Eve (La Vigilia) often features the Feast of the Seven Fishes, especially in southern Italy. It’s a meatless meal full of seafood dishes, homemade pasta, and fresh vegetables.
- Christmas Day (Il Giorno di Natale) is reserved for abundant family feasts, including roasted meats, stuffed pasta, and beloved sweets like panettone and pandoro.
Many Italian families still use recipes passed down through generations—like the famous pasta della nonna (grandmother’s pasta). These are dishes made lovingly by hand, often with fresh eggs, flour, and herbs, and served in large bowls at the center of the table.
At Pasta Class Florence, we celebrate these traditions every day. Our cooking classes teach guests how to make pasta fatta in casa just like Italian nonnas do—connecting you to the heart of Italy through its food.
Music & Entertainment: Carols vs. Choirs
In the United States, Christmas is shaped heavily by pop culture. Classic films like Home Alone, Elf, and The Grinch are holiday staples, while stores play Christmas carols on loop starting in late November. From jazz to country to pop, every genre has its own holiday playlist.
Italy takes a more traditional approach. During the season, you’ll hear religious hymns, regional folk songs, and live music performances in piazzas and churches. Choirs, orchestras, and even string quartets bring an elegant and spiritual soundtrack to the season.
Decorations: Lights, Presepi & Timeless Charm
When it comes to decorations, American neighborhoods often go all-out. Giant inflatables, choreographed light shows, and neon-lit Santas dominate front lawns. Malls transform into winter wonderlands with fake snow and Christmas carols.
In Italy, the atmosphere is more refined. Cities like Florence light up with twinkling string lights, elegant Christmas trees in historic piazzas, and handcrafted nativity scenes in windows and churches. There’s less emphasis on commercial flash and more on timeless tradition.
In fact, one of the most beautiful ways to experience Christmas in Florence is by strolling the cobblestone streets, sipping a Vin Brulé, and admiring the warm glow of lights against centuries-old architecture.
Want to Celebrate Like an Italian?
If you’re spending Christmas in Florence or planning a future holiday trip, immerse yourself in Italian food traditions with Pasta Class Florence. Learn how to make homemade pasta using recipes that have been passed down for generations. It’s the perfect way to connect with Italian culture, whether you’re a first-time visitor or a long-time lover of Italy.
You can also pair your culinary adventures with a Tuscan wine tasting. Visit Your Vino for curated wine experiences across Florence and Tuscany—perfect for the festive season!
One Spirit, Two Cultures
In the end, both Italy and the United States celebrate Christmas with love, joy, and family at the heart of it all. Whether you’re sipping eggnog next to a sparkling tree in New York or sharing pasta fatta in casa in a candlelit kitchen in Florence, the magic is the same: togetherness, tradition, and gratitude.
Buon Natale & Merry Christmas — may your season be full of good food, sweet memories, and plenty of pasta!
Want to learn how to make your own Christmas pasta at home?
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel for free recipes and tips from our chefs in Florence!
Buon Natale and Merry Christmas, wherever you are!